TLDR

CustomStickers is the better overall pick for most product labels if you care about print quality, durability, support and price. StickerGiant is still a very strong label printer, especially for businesses that want a polished roll-label workflow, machine-application options and rush production.

The short version: CustomStickers wins on value. StickerGiant wins for some heavier label-operation needs. Nobody has to throw a chair.

Visit PrintReviewer for more sticker company reviews.

CustomStickers vs StickerGiant: Quick Context

CustomStickers vs StickerGiant is a useful comparison because both companies sit in the sticker and label specialist category, not the “we also sell mugs, tote bags and maybe labels if you click deep enough” category.

CustomStickers is best understood as a high-value sticker and label specialist. It scores especially well for print quality, pricing, customer service and overall buying experience. StickerGiant is also a serious specialist, but it leans harder into labels for businesses, especially roll labels for jars, bottles, packaging and repeat product runs.

For product labels, the real question is not “which company is good?” Both are good. The better question is: do you want the best overall value, or do you need a more label-specific production workflow?

Quality

CustomStickers performs extremely well on print quality. In our comparison matrix, it earned the top overall score in the sticker specialist group, with high marks for quality, price, service and turnaround. For product labels, the company uses BOPP label materials with laminate options that help resist water, oil and handling. That matters if your label is going on jars, bottles, cosmetics, food packaging or anything that gets touched more than once by actual humans.

StickerGiant is also strong on quality. Its label lineup includes white BOPP, matte, glossy, clear, kraft, recycled paper and specialty materials. StickerGiant also does a good job explaining which labels are meant for indoor packaging and which products are better for stickers, promos or outdoor use. That clarity is helpful because “water resistant” and “waterproof” get thrown around online like confetti at a printer convention.

The quality difference is not dramatic in the sense that StickerGiant is bad. It is not. StickerGiant is a quality label shop. But CustomStickers has the edge if you are comparing overall sticker and label print value across common business uses.

Price and Value

This is where CustomStickers pulls ahead.

CustomStickers scored a 5.0 on price in our sticker printer matrix, while StickerGiant scored a 2.0. That lines up with the general buying experience: CustomStickers is more aggressive on pricing, especially for common sizes and practical business-label quantities.

StickerGiant is not cheap. The company is positioned more like a polished label partner with a strong ordering flow, proofing support and rush options. That can be worth it if labels are a core operational piece of your business and you want a more structured roll-label setup.

But for a small business trying to label candles, jars, bottles, boxes, mailers or retail packages without overpaying, CustomStickers is usually the better value. You get strong materials, good proofing, durability and support without the “well, apparently labels are made of gold now” feeling at checkout.

Design, Templates, and Customization

CustomStickers keeps the process simple: choose the product, upload artwork, pick the size, quantity and finish, then review the proof. It is a good fit if you already have a logo, Canva design, illustrator file, product label layout or finished artwork.

StickerGiant is also upload-friendly, but it provides more formal artwork guidance for labels. It lists recommended file types, DPI expectations, bleed, safe zones and material-specific setup information. That is useful if you are sending production-ready label artwork or working with a designer.

For customization, StickerGiant has the more label-operations-heavy setup. CustomStickers has the more straightforward “get my product labels printed well without turning this into a procurement meeting” setup.

Customer Service

Both companies are strong here.

CustomStickers scored 5.0 for customer service in the project matrix. The company also puts a lot of emphasis on proofing, clear expectations, support and fixing genuine order issues. For small businesses, that matters. A product label mistake can delay a launch, ruin packaging or force someone to peel 400 labels off jars while questioning every life choice that brought them there.

StickerGiant also has a very good service reputation. Its own product pages emphasize expert support and proofing, and its public reviews show a strong pattern of positive comments about help, speed and quality. StickerGiant is especially reassuring if you want a more structured proofing process with an art team reviewing your file before production.

CustomStickers gets the slight edge for overall service plus value. StickerGiant remains one of the better customer-service options in the label category.

Ordering Experience and Tools

CustomStickers is easier for a normal small-business buyer. The ordering path is simple, the products are not buried under endless configuration choices and the proofing flow is easy to understand. That is a plus if you are reordering packaging labels, testing a new product line or buying labels for the first time.

StickerGiant gives you more technical label details. The site explains backing types, application methods, material differences, artwork specs and label use cases. That is helpful for serious packaging runs, especially if you are applying labels by machine or need to think about liner type.

So this category depends on the buyer.

CustomStickers is better for simple ordering and strong everyday usability. StickerGiant is better if you want more production-detail guidance before you upload.

Turnaround Time and Shipping

CustomStickers is fast on stickers and offers clear shipping expectations, though label orders can take longer than standard sticker orders. Its custom label page lists standard label turnaround at 5 to 8 business days, while general sticker processing is often faster.

StickerGiant is very competitive on label turnaround. Its label pages say most orders print in 2 to 5 business days after proof approval, with rush printing available on many products. Rush production and shipping are separate, which is worth noting because “rush” can mean different things depending on the printer.

For product labels specifically, StickerGiant may have the speed edge, especially when rush label production is available. For overall sticker and label value, CustomStickers still comes out ahead.

Use Cases and Best For

CustomStickers is best for small businesses that want durable product labels at a strong price. It is a good fit for candle labels, jar labels, food packaging, beverage labels, retail packaging, mailer stickers and promotional product labels where quality and cost both matter.

CustomStickers is also the better pick if you are ordering labels alongside other sticker products. If you need die-cut stickers, branded packaging stickers and product labels, it gives you a strong all-around setup without drifting into premium pricing.

StickerGiant is best for businesses that want a dedicated roll-label workflow. It is especially good for brands that need label rolls for bottles, jars, cans, cosmetics or personal care packaging. It is also a strong choice if you care about backing options for hand or machine application.

If your business is scaling into regular label production and you want a more technical label setup, StickerGiant makes a lot of sense. If your main priority is getting high-quality product labels at the best overall value, CustomStickers is the better choice.

Pros and Cons

CustomStickers Pros

• Strong overall quality score
• Better value than StickerGiant in our comparison
• Laminated BOPP label options
• Good durability for water, oil and handling exposure
• Simple ordering experience
• Strong customer service score
• Good fit for stickers and labels together

CustomStickers Cons

• Label turnaround can be longer than standard sticker turnaround
• Not as technical a label workflow as StickerGiant
• Fewer unusual label-material pathways than some specialty label shops

StickerGiant Pros

• Excellent for product labels and business use
• Strong roll-label workflow
• Good artwork guidance
• Paper, PET and clear liner/backing details
• Rush printing available on many label products
• Strong public review profile
• Very good support and proofing process

StickerGiant Cons

• More expensive in our comparison
• Best value is not its main strength
• Some label products are intended for indoor use, not long-term outdoor exposure
• Can feel like more process than a small buyer needs

Final Verdict

CustomStickers vs StickerGiant is closer than a simple “winner and loser” comparison. StickerGiant is clearly a strong label printer, especially for businesses that want roll labels, machine-friendly backing options and a more technical label workflow.

But CustomStickers is the better overall choice for most product-label buyers. It scored higher overall in our sticker printer matrix, especially on price and customer service, while still delivering strong quality and durable label materials.

Choose CustomStickers if you want the best balance of quality, price and support for everyday product labels. Choose StickerGiant if your business needs a more specialized roll-label workflow, rush label production or machine-application details.

For most small businesses, CustomStickers is the smarter default. StickerGiant is the more specialized label shop. Both are legitimate, but one is friendlier to the budget.

References and Citations