Where to buy Indian ingredients in New York City

New York City is a diverse metropolis renowned for its culinary scene, catering to a variety of tastes and flavors from around the world. For those seeking Indian grocery delivery in NYC, the city offers a plethora of stores specializing in authentic spices, produce, and staples. In this blog, we will delve into the pros and cons of five popular Indian ingredient stores in New York City, helping you discover the best options for your daily Indian cooking.

Comparison Table For Best Indian Grocery Delivery Service in New York City

StoreDelivery ChargesNationwide DeliveryOfferingsOrganic Options Available
Quicklly Free on orders above $30YesWide range of Indian ingredients from 100+ partnered stores at affordable rates Yes
Kalustyan’sService Fee of 4.25$ + varied delivery chargesNoExtensive range of Indian ingredientsYes
Patel BrothersFree on orders above $30NoAffordable prices, fresh produceLimited
Dual Specialty$12.98 + Service fee of $15.00NoSpecialty items, regional spicesLimited
Apna BazaarVaries with order NoWide range of Indian ingredientsLimited
Food BazaarService fee of $8.12 + Long distance service fee of $5.00 (Varies)NoVaried international ingredients, including Indian productsLimited
  1. Kalustyan’s

Pros:

  • Vast Selection: Kalustyan’s boasts an extensive range of Indian ingredients, including spices, lentils, rice, flours, and pickles. You’ll find almost everything you need under one roof.
  • Quality and Authenticity: The store is known for its commitment to sourcing high-quality products, ensuring an authentic Indian culinary experience.
  • Specialty Items: Kalustyan’s also offers unique and hard-to-find items like regional spices, herbal remedies, and cooking utensils.

Cons:

  • High Prices: While Kalustyan’s quality is exceptional, its prices tend to be higher than other Indian ingredient stores in the city.
  • Crowded Store: Due to its popularity, Kalustyan’s can get quite crowded, especially during peak hours, making it challenging to navigate through the aisles.
  1. Patel Brothers

Pros:

  • Large Store: With multiple locations in New York City, Patel Brothers offers spacious stores, providing ample room for browsing and exploring a wide variety of Indian ingredients.
  • Fresh Produce: The store is known for its fresh produce section, offering a vibrant array of vegetables, herbs, and fruits.

Cons:

  • Limited Organic Selection: While Patel Brothers has a comprehensive range of ingredients, the availability of organic products might be limited compared to other stores.
  • Inconsistent Stock: Occasionally, certain items may be out of stock, making it necessary to visit at different times to ensure you find everything you need.
  1. Quicklly 

Pros:

  • Convenience: Quicklly is an online platform that offers a wide selection of Indian ingredients, allowing you to shop from the comfort of your own home.
  • Nationwide Delivery: Unlike physical stores, Quicklly offers nationwide delivery, making it accessible to those living outside of New York City.
  • Multiple Options (order Indian grocery online): Quicklly partners with various Indian grocery stores, providing a diverse range of ingredients and brands to choose from.
  • Competitive Prices: Quicklly is renowned for its affordable prices, making it an excellent option for budget-conscious shoppers.

Cons:

  • Delivery Fees: Depending on your location and order size, delivery fees may apply, which could increase the overall cost of your purchase.
  • Specific Dietary Products: Beyond offering vegetarian options, you cannot customize for specific dietary needs
  1. Dual Specialty Store

Pros:

  • Niche Products: Dual Specialty Store is a hidden gem for those seeking unique and rare Indian ingredients. It offers specialty items like regional spices, flours, and snacks that are hard to find elsewhere.
  • Knowledgeable Staff: The store’s staff members are well-versed in Indian cuisine and can provide valuable recommendations and insights.

Cons:

  • Limited Space: Dual Specialty Store is relatively small compared to other Indian ingredient stores, which may lead to a slightly limited selection of mainstream items.
  • Higher Prices for Specialty Items: While the prices for regular ingredients are competitive, specialty items at Dual Specialty Store might be pricier compared to other stores.
  1. Apna Bazaar

Pros:

  • Affordable Prices: Apna Bazaar offers a wide range of Indian ingredients at budget-friendly prices, making it an excellent option for cost-conscious shoppers.
  • Multiple Locations: With several stores across New York City, Apna Bazaar ensures convenience for those residing in different neighborhoods.

Cons:

  • Limited Organic Options: If you specifically seek organic ingredients, Apna Bazaar might not be the best choice, as its organic selection is relatively limited.
  • Store Ambience: Compared to other Indian ingredient stores, Apna Bazaar’s ambiance might be more functional than inviting.
  1. Food Bazaar

Pros:

  • Varied International Selection: Food Bazaar is a supermarket chain that offers a diverse range of international ingredients, including Indian products. It is an ideal option if you wish to explore various cuisines under one roof.
  • Affordable Prices: Food Bazaar is known for its competitive prices, making it an attractive choice for budget-conscious shoppers.

Cons:

  • Limited Specialty Items: While Food Bazaar provides a wide range of general Indian ingredients, it may have a limited selection of specialty items.
  • Limited delivery: Food Bazar delivers only to limited pincodes in the NYC area.