A new study from Kevin McManus Law has uncovered a troubling trend in traffic safety: drivers of higher-priced vehicles, whether luxury sedans or large pickups, are disproportionately involved in crashes across the United States and Missouri.
The report, based on 2023 data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Missouri State Highway Patrol, reveals that car price and crash risk are closely linked. The findings underscore a national safety concern: more expensive vehicles may carry more than financial weight; they may also carry greater risk.
The National Picture: Crash Fatalities Are On the Rise
According to NHTSA, 40,990 people died in motor vehicle crashes in the U.S. in 2023, an average of over 112 deaths every day. Missouri’s roads reflect this disturbing trend, with 991 crash-related fatalities last year, including 102 deaths in Kansas City alone.
Shockingly, 53% of Missouri’s fatal crashes involved pickup trucks or SUVs, vehicles that are not only the state’s most popular but also among its most expensive. According to the report, the Ford F-150, Chevrolet Silverado, and Toyota RAV4 are the most commonly driven vehicles in Missouri, with median price tags ranging from $33,000 to nearly $59,000.
Luxury Cars: A National Problem
While Missouri is saturated with powerful trucks and SUVs, the national data adds another layer: luxury brands are consistently among the most crash-involved vehicles. Of the top 10 accident-prone brands in the U.S., 40% are considered luxury or high-end.
The study found the following luxury vehicles had the highest accident rates per 1,000 drivers:
- Tesla – 36.94
- Audi – 32.23
- BMW – 30.43
- Infiniti – 29.37
- Lexus – 28.67
- Acura – 28.44
- Mercedes-Benz – 26.39
- Volvo – 26.35
- Land Rover – 25.97
- Lincoln – 21.59
“Many of these vehicles come with five-star crash ratings,” said a spokesperson for Kevin McManus Law. “But even the best safety tech can’t prevent crashes caused by human behavior especially speeding, distraction, and aggression.”
The Psychology of Expensive Driving
The study draws on behavioral psychology to explain the trend. One particularly eye-opening finding: for every $1,000 increase in a vehicle’s value, the odds of its driver yielding to a pedestrian drop by 3%.
“Drivers in more expensive vehicles often feel more entitled or less accountable,” said the spokesperson. “They may drive faster, take more risks, or pay less attention. And the data is backing that up.”
Even though the median household income in the U.S. is $80,610, many Americans are driving vehicles well above recommended affordability thresholds. In Missouri, where the median household income is $68,920 (and $67,449 in Kansas City), popular vehicles like the Ford F-150 can cost nearly $60,000—almost an entire year’s salary.
Crash Causes in Missouri: Speeding, Alcohol, and Distraction
The report also breaks down crash causes in Missouri:
- 53% of fatal crashes involved speeding
- 17% involved alcohol
- 10% were attributed to distracted driving
In many of these cases, the driver was behind the wheel of a pickup, SUV, or luxury vehicle, suggesting a strong link between vehicle type, cost, and aggressive driving behavior.
Kansas City’s Deadliest Roads in 2023
The data also reveals where these crashes are happening. Kansas City’s top 10 high-fatality roadways in 2023 include:
- I-435 – 26 fatalities
- Truman Road – 12
- U.S. 71 – 11
- I-70 – 11
- Prospect Avenue – 9
- Ward Parkway – 8
- Troost Avenue – 7
- Independence Avenue – 6
- Emanuel Cleaver II Blvd. – 4
- 31st Street – 4
“These numbers don’t lie,” said the spokesperson. “We’re seeing the same roads, the same behaviors, and the same high-risk vehicles involved again and again.”
Policy and Public Safety Recommendations
In response to the findings, Kevin McManus Law is calling for a multi-pronged approach to reduce crash risk and increase accountability:
- Strengthened seatbelt enforcement, especially for pickup and SUV occupants, where unbelted fatalities are disproportionately high.
- Statewide safety campaigns targeted at high-risk drivers and vehicle types.
- Better road infrastructure and signage on Missouri’s most dangerous roads.
- Incentivizing safer vehicles, including subsidies or insurance discounts for cars with built-in driver-assist tech.
- Behavioral education, especially for young or high-income drivers, focuses on speeding, distraction, and pedestrian safety.
Driving Toward Safer Roads
“This isn’t just a Missouri problem, it’s a national problem with local consequences,” said Kevin McManus. “Every time a driver gets behind the wheel of a $70,000 SUV or a high-performance sedan, they’re taking on a responsibility far beyond their safety. And the numbers show that far too often, that responsibility is being ignored.”
The bottom line: more expensive cars are consistently linked to higher accident rates—and changing that will require more than better seatbelts or airbags. It will take accountability, infrastructure, and education.