In the heart of Otisville, New York, you’ll find more than just a hardware store—you’ll find a community staple. Otisville Hardware, located at 10 Wallace Street, Otisville NY 10963, is more than a place to pick up nails or paint. It’s a trusted neighborhood resource built on helpful service, knowledgeable staff, and a wide selection of products to meet every project need—big or small.
Whether you’re a seasoned contractor, weekend DIYer, or first-time homeowner, Otisville Hardware is your reliable partner for tools, supplies, and know-how. And with the motto, “If we don’t have it, you don’t need it,” this store takes pride in stocking exactly what you need—when you need it.
Open 7 Days – Because Projects Can’t Wait
Life doesn’t slow down—and neither do your home and work projects. That’s why Otisville Hardware is open 7 days a week, providing the flexibility and convenience you deserve. Whether it’s a last-minute plumbing fix or prepping for a weekend gardening session, the doors are open when you need them.
What You’ll Find at Otisville Hardware
Otisville Hardware is proud to carry a diverse selection of hardware, fasteners, building materials, and more. Their inventory is designed to support everyday homeowners, hobbyists, and professionals alike.
Welding Gases and Supplies
For the metalworking community, the store offers welding gas refills including Argon/CO2, Acetylene, and Oxygen. Plus, they carry Forney welding supplies, making it a one-stop destination for both consumables and accessories.
Plumbing & Electrical
Whether you’re fixing a leak or upgrading your lighting, you’ll find a full array of plumbing and electrical supplies, along with expert guidance to help you get it right the first time.
Automotive & Hydraulic Services
Otisville Hardware also offers custom hydraulic hose fabrication, a rare service in small-town hardware stores. Plus, automotive fluids, tools, and parts ensure you’re covered from the workshop to the garage.
Key Cutting & Paint Mixing
Need an extra set of keys? Otisville Hardware provides custom key duplication while you shop. Looking to refresh a room or stain your deck? Their paint, stains, and sundries section has everything you need, with staff ready to help you pick the right finish or shade.
Seasonal & Outdoor Essentials
Otisville Hardware adapts to your seasonal needs with winter ice melt, roof repair materials, and insulation and weatherization supplies to keep your home safe and warm.
In spring and summer, visit their greenhouse, filled with annual plants and fall mums that add vibrant life to your outdoor spaces. From fertilizers and soils to pest control products, the garden section is ready to help your landscape thrive.
Pet, Bird, and Household Goods
It’s not just tools and lumber. Otisville Hardware also stocks housewares, cleaning supplies, pet care items, and bird food. It’s your go-to for daily household essentials—saving you trips across town.
Lumber & Drainage Supplies
Need building materials? The store carries convenience lumber, drainage pipes, and ground maintenance supplies for everything from garden edging to full outdoor construction projects.
Plus, if you’re heating with pellets, they offer Lignetics wood pellets—a reliable, clean-burning fuel option that’s easy to store and use.
Why Choose Otisville Hardware?
- Locally Owned and Operated
- Helpful and Experienced Staff
- Extensive Product Range
- Specialty Services like Welding Gas, Key Cutting & Hydraulic Hoses
- Open Every Day
When you shop at Otisville Hardware, you’re supporting a local business that’s committed to the community. Their team understands the value of personalized service, quality products, and honest advice—and it shows in every customer interaction.
Visit Today
Located at 10 Wallace Street in Otisville, NY, Otisville Hardware invites you to stop by and experience the difference of shopping local. Whether you’re picking up one bolt or planning a big project, they’ve got the inventory, service, and know-how to get you through it.